Did a ‘Terror’ Fan Crack the Case of the Lost Franklin Expedition?

From Fandom to Fact: How a ‘Terror’ Fan Helped Solve a 170-Year-Old Mystery

It’s a captivating tale of obsession, meticulous research, and a happy accident that bridges the gap between fiction and reality. The AMC series The Terror, a chilling dramatization of the ill-fated Franklin Expedition, has unexpectedly fueled a real-life historical breakthrough. Thanks to the dedication of a fan, Fabiënne Tetteroo, researchers have finally identified the remains of Captain Francis Fitzjames, one of the highest-ranking officers lost in the Arctic tragedy. This discovery, made possible by a compelling intersection of fandom and rigorous academic work, sheds new light on one of history’s most enduring mysteries.

The Franklin Expedition, launched in 1845, aimed to chart the elusive Northwest Passage. Two ships, HMS Erebus and HMS Terror, sailed into the Arctic with 128 men, only to become trapped by sea ice. After a year of being icebound, the ships were abandoned. The remaining crew attempted a desperate march south across the treacherous Arctic landscape, hoping to reach civilization. They were never seen again.

AMC’s The Terror masterfully fictionalizes the expedition’s horrifying final days, weaving a tale of starvation, disease, mutiny, and even a supernatural threat. While the show takes creative liberties, it effectively captures the bleak realities faced by the explorers. The series highlights the suffering endured by men like Captain Francis Crozier (brilliantly portrayed by Jared Harris) and Captain Fitzjames (played by Tobias Menzies). The show depicts the death of nearly all expedition members, leaving only one survivor in its narrative arc.

In reality, the fate of the Franklin Expedition remains one of history’s most enduring mysteries. All 128 men perished, their bodies scattered across King William Island. Evidence of cannibalism emerged over the years, further fueling the grim fascination surrounding this catastrophic journey. For over 170 years, historians and researchers have painstakingly pieced together the events leading to the expedition’s demise, slowly identifying scattered remains and attempting to establish the identities of the lost sailors.

Prior to Tetteroo’s contribution, only a few men had been positively identified. The process is incredibly complex, requiring painstaking forensic work, analysis of scant surviving records, and—crucially—DNA matching with living descendants. This is where Fabiënne Tetteroo, a naval historian and devoted fan of The Terror, entered the picture.

Tetteroo’s passion for the Franklin Expedition ignited after watching The Terror. She became particularly engrossed in the life of Captain Fitzjames, inspired by William Battersby’s biography. This fascination propelled her into extensive independent research, culminating in her own biography of Fitzjames. While a fan of the historical events depicted in the show, she’s been outspoken about her feelings regarding the show’s characterization of Fitzjames. On social media, she stated that the show’s portrayal of Fitzjames, "misrepresents the real guy." This highlights the unique relationship between historical accuracy and fictional interpretation, often highlighting the gap between the creative liberties of a show and the stark realities of historical fact.

Her dedication and meticulous research proved invaluable. Tetteroo used her knowledge to connect researchers with a descendant of Fitzjames, providing a crucial link in the chain of DNA evidence. This vital connection was explicitly acknowledged by the researchers involved in the groundbreaking identification of Fitzjames’s remains. In the paper detailing their findings, the researchers wrote: "Sincere thanks are extended to Fabiënne Tetteroo for generously sharing the results of her investigations of Fitzjames’ family history and for her efforts to identify possible candidates for our Franklin expedition DNA research. It was through her efforts that we were connected with the descendant donor."

This acknowledgement underscores the crucial role Tetteroo played in the discovery. Her work, driven by her passion for history and inspired by a television series, unlocked a significant piece of the puzzle. While Tetteroo has stressed that her motivation stemmed from historical curiosity rather than pure fandom, her story highlights the powerful, positive impact that engaged fans can have on historical research.

This remarkable collaboration between a dedicated fan and dedicated researchers demonstrates the unexpected links between popular culture and historical investigation. The enduring fascination with the Franklin Expedition, amplified by The Terror, has provided an irresistible hook for engaging the public and furthering historical understanding.

The identification of Captain Fitzjames’s remains is not simply a remarkable feat of forensic science. It is a poignant reminder of the human cost of exploration, the resilience of historical inquiry, and the surprising ways in which enthusiasm, even that born of fictional storytelling, can help uncover the truth about the past. The discovery also confirmed, through visible evidence on the remains, that Captain Fitzjames was a victim of cannibalism, a grim reality of the expedition’s final days.

The story also serves as a broader example of citizen science. The involvement of an amateur historian, guided by her deep passion, has directly contributed to a substantial academic breakthrough. This phenomenon is becoming increasingly common in various fields, highlighting the collaborative nature of knowledge creation in the 21st century. What started as an appreciation for a dramatized version of a historic tragedy blossomed into a genuine contribution to historical understanding and the resolution of a long-standing evidentiary puzzle.

Fabiënne Tetteroo’s contribution transcends simple fandom; it represents the power of dedicated research, the importance of community engagement, and the unexpected connections that can occur between popular entertainment and scholarly pursuit. Her story stands as a testament to the fact that the pursuit of knowledge, however ignited, can lead to profound discoveries and contribute to a much fuller picture of our shared past. And, perhaps, it serves as an excellent recommendation to watch The Terror—both for its dramatic storytelling and for its inspiring role in bringing a piece of history to light.

Article Reference